You are here

The Herb Elimination Game: IT GOES ON

YES. ANOTHER GAME.

We are considering both the fresh and dried versions of these herbs.

the rules:

1. You may vote once daily.
2. Vote by adding a point to an herb you like, and subtracting a point from an herb you don't like.
3. Once an herb has 0 points, it is eliminated and cannot be voted for again.
4. (tentative) Once the game has come to a near standstill and all the herbs left have high points, we'll determine the winner by putting it to a poll where you can vote for one option.

The list:
5 Basil
5 Thai basil
5 Bay
5 Borage
5 Chamomile
5 Chervil
5 Chives
5 Cilantro
5 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
5 Lavender
5 Lemongrass
5 Lemon balm
5 Marjoram
5 Oregano
5 Pandan
5 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
5 Peppermint
5 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
5 Shiso/perilla/beefsteak plant
5 Spearmint
5 Tarragon
5 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

24 Basil +1
2 Thai Basil -1
24 Cilantro
20 Curry leaves
14 Dill
10 Kaffir lime leaves
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
17 Rosemary

0 likes

25 Basil +1
2 Thai Basil nu uh
24 Cilantro
20 Curry leaves
14 Dill
9 Kaffir lime leaves -1
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
17 Rosemary

0 likes

25 Basil
2 Thai Basil nu uh
24 Cilantro
20 Curry leaves
14 Dill  +1
9 Kaffir lime leaves
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary  -1  I'm down with rosemary, but as our list gets shorter I have to pick something.

0 likes

You didn't add to dill then.

25 Basil
2 Thai Basil
24 Cilantro
20 Curry leaves
15 Dill 
9 Kaffir lime leaves
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

25 Basil
1 Thai Basil  -1 (only good for Thai curries!)
24 Cilantro
21 Curry leaves  +1
15 Dill
9 Kaffir lime leaves
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

25 Basil
0 Thai Basil -1 ELIMINATED
24 Cilantro
22 Curry leaves +1
15 Dill
9 Kaffir lime leaves
21 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

sOooo, you curry-leaves-voters. what do they taste like?

0 likes

On second thoughts... I'm just not going to play anymore. ::) The things I love are gone, and I don't hate any of the things which remain enough to vote them down.

0 likes

25 Basil
24 Cilantro
22 Curry leaves
15 Dill
8 Kaffir lime leaves (-1)
22 Lemongrass (+1)
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

26 Basil +1
24 Cilantro
22 Curry leaves
15 Dill
7 Kaffir lime leaves -1
22 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro +1
22 Curry leaves
14 Dill -1 tasty at times, but not as versatile
7 Kaffir lime leaves
22 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
16 Rosemary

0 likes

how many should we get it down to? 5?

0 likes

sOooo, you curry-leaves-voters. what do they taste like?

They taste like curry leaves. Hard to describe. Very unique flavor (pungent smell too!), but fucking delicious. No South Indian curry is complete without curry leaves (and coconut)

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro
23 Curry leaves  +1
14 Dill
7 Kaffir lime leaves
22 Lemongrass
16 Oregano
15 Rosemary  -1

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro
23 Curry leaves
14 Dill
6 Kaffir lime leaves  -1
22 Lemongrass
17 Oregano  +1
15 Rosemary

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro
23 Curry leaves
15 Dill  +1
6 Kaffir lime leaves
22 Lemongrass
17 Oregano
14 Rosemary  -1

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro
23 Curry leaves
14 Dill -1
6 Kaffir lime leaves
22 Lemongrass
17 Oregano
15 Rosemary +1

0 likes

26 Basil
25 Cilantro
24 Curry leaves +1
13 Dill -1
6 Kaffir lime leaves
22 Lemongrass
17 Oregano
15 Rosemary

0 likes

WHAT THE HELL, YOU DILL HATERS!!!

0 likes

not a dill hater, just like the other things more! sorry!  : /

0 likes

Pages

Log in or register to post comments