You are here

Home » Community » The Kitchen Sink » The Herb Elimination Game: IT GOES ON

The Herb Elimination Game: IT GOES ON

Posted by faunablues on Jul 26, 2011 · Member since Aug 2003 · 9655 posts

YES. ANOTHER GAME.

We are considering both the fresh and dried versions of these herbs.

the rules:

1. You may vote once daily.
2. Vote by adding a point to an herb you like, and subtracting a point from an herb you don't like.
3. Once an herb has 0 points, it is eliminated and cannot be voted for again.
4. (tentative) Once the game has come to a near standstill and all the herbs left have high points, we'll determine the winner by putting it to a poll where you can vote for one option.

The list:
5 Basil
5 Thai basil
5 Bay
5 Borage
5 Chamomile
5 Chervil
5 Chives
5 Cilantro
5 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
5 Lavender
5 Lemongrass
5 Lemon balm
5 Marjoram
5 Oregano
5 Pandan
5 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
5 Peppermint
5 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
5 Shiso/perilla/beefsteak plant
5 Spearmint
5 Tarragon
5 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

Posted by laurenlovesgoodies on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Nov 2007 · 2936 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
9 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
5 Lavender
5 Lemongrass
5 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
6 Oregano
2 Pandan
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
5 Peppermint
7 Rosemary +1
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
2 Tarragon -1
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Minke on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Feb 2010 · 3503 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
5 Lavender
5 Lemongrass
6 Lemon balm (+1)
6 Marjoram
6 Oregano
1 Pandan (-1)
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
6 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
2 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by secondbase on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Dec 2005 · 5540 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
7 Cilantro  -1
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
5 Lavender
6 Lemongrass  +1
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
6 Oregano
1 Pandan
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
6 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
2 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by monkey7 on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Sep 2009 · 324 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
7 Cilantro 
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender -1
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
6 Oregano
1 Pandan
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint +1
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
2 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by faunablues on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Aug 2003 · 9655 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro (+1) 
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavende
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
6 Oregano
1 Pandan
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
1 Tarragon (-1) SOMEONE KILL IT. I HATE THIS THING
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by shelloid on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Nov 2006 · 4427 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
5 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
7 Oregano +1
0 Pandan -1 ELIMINATED!!!
2 Curly parsley
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
1 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by humboldt_honey on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Feb 2007 · 12529 posts

9 Basil
6 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill  +1
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
7 Oregano
1 Curly parsley  -1
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
1 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by amymylove on Jul 29, 2011 · Member since Apr 2009 · 5266 posts

9 Basil
7 Thai basil    +1
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill 
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
6 Marjoram
7 Oregano
0 Curly parsley  ELIMINATED... mine as well...
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
1 Tarragon
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Heliamphora on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Oct 2006 · 4798 posts

9 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
3 Borage
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
6 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram +1
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
0 Tarragon BYEE
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Storm on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Sep 2006 · 4238 posts

9 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay     
2 Borage -1
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
9 Cilantro +1
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass   
6 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Minke on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Feb 2010 · 3503 posts

9 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
1 Borage (-1)
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
9 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm (+1)
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
4 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by charlie_fo_farley on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Feb 2011 · 618 posts

9 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
2 Borage  + 1
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
9 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
3 Shiso    -1
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by faunablues on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Aug 2003 · 9655 posts

10 Basil (+1)
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
1 Borage  -1
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
9 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
5 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
3 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by secondbase on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Dec 2005 · 5540 posts

10 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
1 Borage 
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro  -1
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves  +1
4 Lavender
6 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
7 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
3 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by monkey7 on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Sep 2009 · 324 posts

10 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
1 Borage 
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
6 Chives
8 Cilantro 
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves 
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass  +1
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary -1
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
3 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by laurenlovesgoodies on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Nov 2007 · 2936 posts

10 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
0 Borage -1 Eliminated
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
7 Chives +1
8 Cilantro 
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves 
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary
5 Saffron
5 Sage
5 Savory
3 Shiso
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by shelloid on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Nov 2006 · 4427 posts

10 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
7 Chives
8 Cilantro 
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves 
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary
5 Saffron
6 Sage +1
5 Savory
2 Shiso -1
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Allychristine on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Dec 2007 · 15438 posts

11 Basil +1
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
7 Chives
8 Cilantro 
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves 
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass 
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary
5 Saffron
6 Sage
5 Savory
1 Shiso -1
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Heliamphora on Jul 30, 2011 · Member since Oct 2006 · 4798 posts

11 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
5 Chamomile
4 Chervil
7 Chives
9 Cilantro +1
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass
7 Lemon balm
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary
5 Saffron
6 Sage
5 Savory
0 Shiso eliminated
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes
Posted by Minke on Jul 31, 2011 · Member since Feb 2010 · 3503 posts

11 Basil
7 Thai basil
5 Bay   
5 Chamomile
3 Chervil (-1)
7 Chives
9 Cilantro
7 Curry leaves
6 Dill
5 Fennel leaves
6 Kaffir lime leaves
4 Lavender
7 Lemongrass
8 Lemon balm (+1)
7 Marjoram
7 Oregano
5 Flat-leaf parsley
7 Peppermint
6 Rosemary
5 Saffron
6 Sage
5 Savory
7 Thyme
5 Lemon thyme

0 likes

Pages

Log in or register to post comments
+ Login to Add a Recipe

More Posts Like This